Clay Gravesande and AD Smith decided not to pursue a future together. Clay’s reluctance to marry, stemming from witnessing his father’s unfaithfulness, was a significant concern. Despite AD’s assurance that they could overcome any obstacle as a couple, everything changed at the altar. Clay chose not to say “I do,” explaining that it wouldn’t be fair to commit when he felt unprepared for marriage.
This decision left everyone in shock. Clay promised to work on himself for AD, admitting he wasn’t ready to fully commit to marriage. He emphasized that AD deserved someone who could give her their all, and he couldn’t be that person at the moment.
AD was heartbroken, feeling that their time together had been wasted. Clay’s reasons for ending things included not only emotional readiness but also financial considerations. He questioned his readiness for marriage and love, ultimately realizing he wasn’t prepared for either.
At a reunion, Clay expressed regret over his decision, showing interest in rekindling their relationship. However, AD remained non-committal about their future together. She revealed that she had been on a few dates with fellow cast member Matthew Duliba after the show, but they were not in a relationship.