In an exciting move during the first week of free agency, the Pittsburgh Steelers have made a significant addition to their team by acquiring both Russell Wilson and Justin Fields. This decision has transformed their quarterback lineup, introducing a nine-time Pro Bowler and a former first-round pick known for his potential yet to be fully realized.
The Steelers have made it clear to Fields that Wilson will be taking the lead as the starting quarterback. This announcement came directly from Mike Tomlin to Wilson, confirming there won’t be a competition for the position. However, the question arises: Is Wilson truly the better choice for the team’s success?
According to Stephen Oh, a data scientist from CBS Sports, the Steelers have a higher chance of reaching the playoffs with Fields as the quarterback. With Wilson, their chances were at 25.6%, but with Fields, it jumps to 35.9%.
When comparing the two quarterbacks, several factors come into play, including experience, potential, overall ability, and intangibles.
Wilson’s extensive experience in the NFL gives him a notable advantage. With 204 career starts and 124 wins, including nine playoff victories, his familiarity with various offensive strategies and the seasonal dynamics of the league is invaluable.
On the other hand, Fields brings a fresh perspective and untapped potential. Despite concerns about his accuracy, his impressive mobility and strong arm offer a new dynamic to the Steelers’ offense. Fields’ youth and resilience also present a lower risk of wear and tear compared to Wilson, who has faced a significant number of sacks throughout his career.
Considering overall ability, Fields’ mobility and potential for making significant plays give him an edge over Wilson. However, Wilson’s accuracy and experience cannot be overlooked.
Wilson’s ability to integrate into the Steelers’ environment, supported by his interactions with key team members, highlights his potential as a leader. Yet, Fields’ proven resilience and performance under pressure, especially during his time at Ohio State, demonstrate his intangible qualities as well.
When evaluating their fit for the 2024 Steelers, Wilson’s experience and leadership qualities make him a suitable choice for leading the team, especially given the current state of the Steelers’ offense. Fields, coming from a challenging situation with the Bears, might need more time to adjust to a new system and teammates.
Ultimately, while it’s a close call, Wilson emerges as the preferable option for the Steelers at the season’s start. The future will depend on how both quarterbacks adapt and perform in their new roles.
This strategic move by the Steelers not only revitalizes their quarterback room but also sets the stage for an intriguing season ahead, with the potential for unexpected developments as both Wilson and Fields find their place in the team.